Maine Moving toward the Truth about the Mortgages, MERS and Foreclosures
Originally posted on September 5, 2014 by Neil Garfield
Article by Elena A. Lovoy and D. Brian O’Dell
The Maine Supreme Court has been active in the last few months – issuing several decisions that will likely impact foreclosure actions in that state. The decisions covered a full range of foreclosure issues, from whether a lender can establish standing when it holds an assignment of the mortgage from Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems, Inc. (“MERS”) to the amount a borrower must pay to cure a default. If you originate and/or service RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE LOANS in this state, you may want to review these recent cases. This alert focuses on the court’s holdings in one of these cases, Bank of America, N.A. v. Greenleaf, — A.3d —-, 2014 WL 2988236 (Me., July 3, 2014) (Review the Maine Supreme Court Opinion.)
Assignment from MERS May Only Transfer Right to Record Mortgage. The Maine Supreme Court’s decision in Greenleaf may require lenders to make some changes before they initiate FORECLOSURE action in this state in which the mortgage identifies MERS as the nominee for the lender. This case presented some simple basic facts, but the court’s holdings may raise concerns. In 2006, Scott Greenleaf executed a promissory note for $385,000 to RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE Services, Inc. (“RMS”) and signed a mortgage securing the debt. The note was endorsed in blank. The mortgage listed RMS as the lender and MERS as the nominee for the lender.
In 2011, Bank of America, N.A. (“BofA”) initiated FORECLOSURE proceedings against Greenleaf. It was undisputed that Greenleaf had failed to make payments on the loan since 2008. Although some interim drama played out in the FORECLOSURE proceeding, a trial was held in 2013. BofA presented the following documents to the court: the original note, the mortgage, and a document recorded in 2011 reflecting the assignment of the mortgage from MERS to BAC Home Loans Servicing, LP (“BAC”), an entity that subsequently merged with BofA. The court entered a judgment of FORECLOSURE in favor of BofA and Greenleaf appealed. Greenleaf alleged, among other things, that BofA lacked standing to seek foreclosure of the property since BofA did not have an interest in both the promissory note and the mortgage securing that note. Since the note was endorsed in blank and BofA had possession of the note, the Maine Supreme Court held that BofA met the first prong of the standing test. However, the court found that BofA failed to establish the second prong of the test, ownership of the mortgage.
The court struggled with the 2011 assignment of the mortgage by MERS to BAC. The court focused on one sentence in the 2006 mortgage that specifically provided that MERS was the mortgagee of record for purposes of recording the mortgage. The court held that this provision of the mortgage only granted MERS the right to record the mortgage as the lender’s nominee. When MERS then assigned its interest to BAC, the court held that it granted BAC only the right that it possessed, the right to record the mortgage as nominee for the lender. When BAC then merged with BofA, BofA only obtained the right that BAC had possessed, the right to record the mortgage as nominee.
The court also noted that there was no separate and independent assignment of the mortgage from RMS to MERS, BAC, or BofA. As such, the court held that the record only demonstrated a series of assignments of the right to record the mortgage as nominee. In the absence of evidence that BofA owned the Greenleaf mortgage, the Maine Supreme Court held that BofA lacked standing to seek foreclosure and vacated the lower court’s judgment of foreclosure.
Since similar “right to record” language is included in many mortgage forms, lenders and servicers should pay particular attention to whether they are relying on assignments from MERS before initiating a foreclosure action in this state. Unless a lender holds or can obtain an assignment of the mortgage from the originating lender (and many of this lenders may no longer be in business), a lender may need to explore other options for establishing the second prong of the standing test in Maine. A mortgage assignment by MERS, standing alone, may not be sufficient to prove an assignment of a mortgage.
In response to the Greenleaf decision, many of the title insurers in the state have issued guidance regarding title issues under various scenarios in which MERS had assigned the mortgages. At least one title insurer has indicated that if MERS assigned the mortgage in a pending foreclosure action, an assignment from the original lender to the foreclosing mortgagee will be required in order for title to be insured without exception.
No Adjustments to Disclosed Payoff Amount Permitted During Cure Period. The Greenleaf court also defined the amount a borrower can be required to pay to cure a default. The notice of default and right to cure sent to Greenleaf included an itemization of all past due amounts and identified the total amount required to be paid by Greenleaf to cure the default. This total amount included a footnote reference that Greenleaf should “[c]ontact the servicer to obtain an up to date figure for outstanding attorney fees, unpaid taxes and costs before sending payment” and the notice also separately provided that Greenleaf should contact BAC at a prescribed telephone number “to obtain an up to date figure before sending payment.” Similar disclosures are generally included in the right to cure notices provided by many lenders and servicers.
Me. Rev. Stat. Ann. tit. 14, § 6111 provides that the contents of the notice of default and right to cure must include, among other things, an itemization of all past due amounts causing the loan to be in default and an itemization of any other charges that must be paid in order to cure the default. Greenleaf argued that the addition of the “call for updated information” references did not meet the statutory requirement that the notice itself must provide an itemization of other charges that must be paid in order to cure the default. The Maine Supreme Court agreed with Greenleaf and held that state law effectively freezes additions to the payoff amount during the cure period.
As such, the amount stated in the notice of default and right to cure is the only amount the borrower can be required to pay to cure the default during the 35 day cure period. Any attorneys’ fees incurred in continuing efforts to recover on the loan and advances made for property taxes or insurance during the cure period – none of these amounts can be added to the amount a borrower may be required to pay to cure the default. The court noted that the incorrect “call for updated information” references in the cure notice were an independent basis on which they could have vacated the lower court’s foreclosure judgment.
Lenders and servicers should work closely with their foreclosure counsel to ensure they can establish standing before initiating a foreclose action in Maine. Lenders and servicers may also want to work with the title insurers to address any title issues that may arise in connection with MERS assignments. With certain changes in their foreclosure practices, lenders and servicers should still be able to prove up ownership of each mortgage sufficient to pass the Greenleaf court’s standing scrutiny. In addition, lenders and servicers should review their cure notice form templates used in this state and any corresponding policies and procedures to ensure that a borrower is never advised or required to pay more than the total amount due as disclosed in the cure notice. The Greenleaf court may have stirred the lobster pot – but lenders and services have options to adapt to the court’s recipes. The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.
Maine Supreme Court Decisions Impacting Foreclosure Actions: Key Insights and How FRAUD STOPPERS Can Help Homeowners
The foreclosure court decisions below made by the Maine Supreme Court have significant implications for foreclosure actions in the state. Lenders and servicers involved in originating and servicing residential mortgage loans need to pay close attention to these rulings as they navigate the foreclosure process. One valuable resource that can assist homeowners facing foreclosure is the FRAUD STOPPERS How to Win in Court Course. Let’s explore how this legal education course can empower homeowners to effectively defend their rights and potentially win their foreclosure cases.
Understanding the Impactful Decisions:
The Maine Supreme Court decisions covered a wide range of foreclosure issues, including establishing standing for lenders with assignments from Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems, Inc. (MERS) and determining the amount borrowers must pay to cure a default. These rulings have introduced new considerations and potential challenges for both lenders and homeowners in foreclosure proceedings.
The FRAUD STOPPERS Advantage:
FRAUD STOPPERS offers a comprehensive legal education course, the How to Win in Court Course, which has been a trusted resource for homeowners for over 23 years. This course provides homeowners with the knowledge and tools they need to navigate the complexities of the legal system and mount a strong defense in foreclosure cases. Here’s how FRAUD STOPPERS can help homeowners facing foreclosure in light of the recent Maine Supreme Court decisions:
1. Learn Case-Winning Tactics:
The course covers everything homeowners need to know to win their cases, providing a step-by-step approach from A to Z. By learning case-winning tactics, homeowners can effectively challenge lenders’ claims and defenses, increasing their chances of a favorable outcome.
2. Save on Legal Fees:
Engaging legal representation can be costly, and many homeowners facing foreclosure may struggle to afford an attorney. FRAUD STOPPERS’ How to Win in Court Course offers an affordable alternative, empowering homeowners to handle their cases pro se (representing themselves) effectively. By eliminating the need for expensive legal fees, homeowners can save money while still mounting a strong defense.
3. Created by an Experienced Attorney:
The course was developed by Dr. Graves, a licensed Florida attorney with over 34 years of experience in winning cases. Dr. Graves recognized the need to educate average individuals on the principles and practices that govern the American judicial system. With his expertise, homeowners gain valuable insights and strategies to level the playing field and effectively challenge lenders’ foreclosure actions.
4. Access to Comprehensive Resources:
The course provides a wealth of resources, including sample legal forms, a 5-hour video seminar divided into 54 individual clips, 25 audio tutorials for download or online listening, 40 in-depth legal tactics classes, at-a-glance charts for quick reference, and an online Q&A forum for getting answers to specific questions. These resources equip homeowners with the necessary knowledge and tools to navigate their foreclosure cases confidently.
5. Covering Any Case, Any Court:
Whether homeowners are dealing with state or federal courts, civil or criminal cases, the FRAUD STOPPERS course is designed to be applicable across various legal scenarios. This flexibility ensures that homeowners can apply the knowledge gained from the course to their specific foreclosure cases, regardless of jurisdiction.
The decision by the Maine Supreme Court have brought new challenges and considerations for homeowners facing foreclosure. By leveraging the resources and expertise provided by the FRAUD STOPPERS How to Win in Court Course, homeowners can level the playing field and effectively defend their rights. With a comprehensive understanding of case-winning tactics and the ability to save on legal fees, homeowners can confidently navigate the foreclosure process and increase their chances of a favorable outcome. Empower yourself with the knowledge and tools offered by FRAUD STOPPERS to fight back against foreclosure and protect your home.
Unlock Your Case-Winning Potential with FRAUD STOPPERS' #1 Pro Se Legal Education Curriculum Since 1997!
Dear Legal Warrior,
Are you tired of feeling helpless in the face of legal battles? Are you seeking the knowledge and tools to confidently navigate the complexities of the judicial system? Look no further! For over 10 years, FRAUD STOPPERS has been the most trusted name in self-help legal education, empowering thousands of individuals like you to successfully win their cases. Now, it's your turn to seize control and secure the legal remedy you deserve!
Introducing How to Win in Court – the comprehensive, step-by-step curriculum designed to equip you with the skills, tactics, and insider knowledge necessary to emerge victorious in any legal battle. Developed by Dr. Graves, a seasoned attorney with an impressive 34 years of experience, this extraordinary program will transform you into a formidable force within the courtroom.
Imagine learning everything you need to know to win your case from A to Z in just 24 hours. With our accelerated learning methods, you can quickly grasp complex legal concepts, saving precious time and hard-earned money on costly legal fees. No more guesswork or relying on inexperienced representation – with How to Win in Court, you become your own advocate, backed by the expertise of a legal professional.
Our comprehensive curriculum leaves no stone unturned. Benefit from a wealth of resources, including:
- Sample legal forms: Gain access to meticulously crafted templates that will streamline your legal document preparation, giving you a competitive edge.
- 5-hour video seminar: Immerse yourself in an in-depth educational experience, consisting of 54 individual clips, where Dr. Graves imparts his invaluable wisdom and insights.
- 25 audio tutorials: Download or listen to online audio tutorials, enabling you to absorb critical legal principles at your convenience.
- 40 in-depth legal tactics classes: Dive deep into specific legal tactics that will sharpen your skills and give you an edge in the courtroom.
- Knowledge at-a-glance charts: Memorize essential information at a glance with our convenient charts, ensuring you're always prepared for battle.
- Online Q&A Forum: Seek answers to your burning questions and receive expert guidance through our exclusive online community of like-minded individuals.
- Online legal research: Access a vast library of resources to bolster your case, enabling you to conduct thorough and effective legal research.
- Final Exam: Test your knowledge and earn an honorary law degree upon successful completion, cementing your expertise in the field.
But that's not all – How to Win in Court offers so much more! Whether you can't afford a lawyer or want to make your current legal representation work harder for you, our program will arm you with the tools to:
- Force witnesses to produce evidence, ensuring a fair and transparent legal process.
- Demand opponent's lawyers to "play fair" and adhere to ethical standards, maintaining a level playing field.
- Persuade judges to sign orders in your favor, securing the outcomes you deserve.
- Ensure everyone involved obeys the rules, preventing unjust actions and preserving your rights.
We understand that learning the intricacies of the legal system may seem daunting. That's why we've crafted our curriculum to be easy to follow, with step-by-step guidance that will build your confidence and empower you to take charge of your legal battles. No matter the nature of your case, whether civil or criminal, state or federal, How to Win in Court will provide the knowledge you need to succeed.
At FRAUD STOPPERS, we are passionate about justice and believe that everyone should have access to fair representation. That's why we've dedicated ourselves to demystifying the legal process and sharing our expertise with individuals like you. With How to Win in Court, you'll not only gain the necessary legal education, but also the unwavering confidence to stand up for your rights and emerge victorious.
Join our community of empowered individuals who have taken control of their legal destiny. Take the first step towards securing the legal remedy you deserve. Visit our website or call 800-459-1215 to enroll in How to Win in Court today. Don't let another moment pass by – become the legal warrior you were meant to be!
Yours in legal empowerment,
FRAUD STOPPERS PMA